Underpayment of workers: are you liable?
Liz Gibbs • February 8, 2018

 

The exploitation of vulnerable workers has been getting a lot of press recently, but did you know that it is not just the company or business involved that may be liable to penalties? In two recent cases, the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) has used accessorial liability laws to successfully obtain penalties from a professional services firm and the HR manager of a business for their involvement in the underpayment of workers.

Exploitation of vulnerable workers has been covered extensively in recent news, whether it be young naive Gen Ys, desperate for a job, or migrant workers who do not know their rights. The Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) has recently used accessorial liability laws to obtain penalties against a professional services firm as well as a HR manager for a restaurant for the underpayment of vulnerable workers.

Recent cases

The professional services firm was a Victorian-based accounting firm, which had provided payroll services to a company and processed wage payments which facilitated $750 of the underpayments in relation to a foreign worker. The accounting firm was penalised $53,880 for facilitating the underpayment, while the company involved was penalised $115,706. In addition to prosecuting companies and firms, the FWO is also prepared to go after individuals. An HR manager for a restaurant in NSW was penalised $21,760 for her role in facilitating what has been described as "wide-scale exploitation of overseas workers".

These cases show that it does not matter what the quantum of the underpayment to workers are, even a small underpayment to workers will result in a large penalty. According to Acting FWO Kristen Hannah:

"[It] is prepared to use accessorial liability laws to hold any party involved in the exploitation of vulnerable workers to account" whether it be the business itself, its internal management, or its advisers.

It is clear from the judgments of the accessorial liability cases that anyone that has been knowingly involved in illegal conduct would be open to these accessorial liability claims. In the case of professional services firms, it must put compliance ahead of its business interests. Similarly, if you work in a business that you know is exploiting workers then according to the presiding judge in the case, "there is nothing wrong with sending the message that an employee should indeed resign if that is the only alternative to continuing to participate knowingly in illegal activity".

What does this mean for your business?

You will need to make sure your workers are getting paid the correct awards, allowances, overtime, and penalty rates. Businesses also need to be aware that the Fair Work Amendment (Protecting Vulnerable Workers) Act 2017 has now come into effect. This means that the maximum penalties are now increased for certain conduct, including the deliberate exploitation of workers and keeping false records.

How about if you are an employee?

If you're the employee of a business and are knowingly involved in underpaying workers, then you may be liable for accessorial liability. This is the case even if you are, or assert that you were, acting on someone else's instructions (as was the case with the HR manager). The Court has made it clear that quitting is a clear alternative.

Contact us for more information

Unsure of what your liabilities are? There are many resources available on the FWO website, or you could consult us, or your payroll services provider, for more information.

Call us at Robert Goodman Accountants on 07 3289 1700 or email us at 
© Copyright 2018. All rights reserved. Source: Thomson Reuters.   Brought to you by Robert Goodman Accountants.
 
minimum pension
By Liz Gibbs May 9, 2025
If you’re receiving an account-based pension from your SMSF, there’s a minimum amount you need to withdraw each year. This amount is worked out using a percentage based on your age and your pension account balance as at 1 July 2024-or on a pro-rata basis if you started your pension partway through the 2025 financial year.
Micro habits big improvements
By Liz Gibbs May 8, 2025
Let’s chat about micro habits—those small, super-manageable actions that can actually lead to some pretty big improvements in how we manage our time and priorities. If you’ve ever left a workshop full of great ideas only to forget them a week later, you’re not alone. That’s where micro habits come in. They’re easy to stick with and surprisingly powerful.
Stay on top of your finances
By Liz Gibbs May 8, 2025
Running a small business can get hectic, but staying on top of your finances doesn’t have to be overwhelming. The ATO has a few helpful tips that can make managing your tax obligations a lot smoother:
CGT small business concessions
By Liz Gibbs May 2, 2025
In a recent decision, the Administrative Review Tribunal ('ART') held that a taxpayer was not entitled to the CGT small business concessions on the disposal of his interests in some farm land.
By Liz Gibbs May 2, 2025
Businesses that pay contractors for 'Taxable payments reporting system services' may need to lodge a 'Taxable payments annual report' ('TPAR') by 28 August each year.
Retirement
By Liz Gibbs May 2, 2025
The amount of money that can be transferred to a tax-free retirement account will increase to $2m on 1 July 2025.
Key tax policies
By Liz Gibbs May 2, 2025
With the 2025 Federal Election approaching, tax policy is a central topic of debate. Here’s a concise comparison of some the major parties’ key tax proposals to help you stay informed when Australia goes to the polls on 3 May 2025:
By Liz Gibbs May 1, 2025
Make Meetings Work for You: 8 Simple Strategies for Better Results
By Liz Gibbs May 1, 2025
The ATO’s updated small business benchmarking tool
subdivision
By Liz Gibbs May 1, 2025
As the urban sprawl continues in most major Australian cities, we are often asked to advise on the tax treatment of subdivision projects. Before jumping in and committing to anything, it is important to understand the tax liabilities that might arise from these projects.
More Posts