PAYG withholding: new penalties for non-compliance
Liz Gibbs • January 12, 2019

Combating the black economy has been a key priority of the government in recent years. To reduce business activity that takes place "under the radar" of the tax system, new laws commencing on 1 July 2019 will prevent businesses from claiming deductions for payments to employees and certain contractors if they fail to comply with their pay-as-you-go (PAYG) withholding and reporting obligations. Although these measures target participants in the black economy, all businesses should understand the new laws to ensure they do not inadvertently risk losing their deductions.

To reduce business activity that takes place "under the radar" of the tax system, new laws commencing on 1 July 2019 will prevent businesses from claiming deductions for payments to employees and certain contractors if they fail to comply with their pay-as-you-go (PAYG) withholding and reporting obligations.

In 2017, a government taskforce on the black economy reported concerns that some Australian businesses are making payments to employees and contractors that are not being properly recorded. In response, the government has acted to deny deductions for payments where businesses fail to comply with the PAYG withholding and reporting rules.

Specifically, new laws commencing on 1 July 2019 will prevent an employer from claiming a deduction for payments to employees such as salary, wages, commissions and bonuses if the employer fails to:

  • withhold an amount from the payment as required under PAYG withholding rules; or
  • report a withholding amount to the ATO as required.

Deductions will similarly be denied for non-compliant payments to directors or religious practitioners, or payments under a labour-hire arrangement.

The new laws also cover non-cash payments, such as goods and services. Generally, businesses must pay a withholding amount to the ATO before making a non-cash payment (equal to the amount they would be required to withhold if the payment were money, based on the market value of the benefit). Under the new laws, businesses will not be allowed to deduct the non-cash payment if they do not comply with the withholding and reporting rules.

Special rules apply for payments to contractors. Businesses are generally required to withhold PAYG from a payment to a contractor where the contractor does not provide their ABN (known as the "no ABN withholding" rules). However, a business that fails to comply with these rules will only be denied a deduction if the payment (either cash or non-cash) relates to a contract for the supply of services; contracts for goods and real property are excluded from the operation of the new laws.

What happens if my business makes a mistake?

If you make a mistake by failing to withhold an amount (or to report it), you will not lose your deduction if you voluntarily disclose this to the ATO before it commences an audit or other compliance activity in relation to your tax affairs. However, you may still incur penalties.

Ensure your business is compliant

Now is a great time to check that your PAYG withholding affairs are in order. Taking early action to correct and disclose PAYG withholding mistakes will make a big difference to whether your business remains eligible for deductions. We can assist you with the process of correcting and disclosing to the ATO any mistakes that may arise.

Call us at Robert Goodman Accountants on 07 3289 1700 or email us at 
reception@rgoodman.com.au .  © Copyright 2018. All rights reserved. Source: Thomson Reuters. 
Brought to you by Robert Goodman Accountants. 
Draw your vision
By Liz Gibbs June 13, 2025
Have you ever wondered how to turn your dreams into reality? According to Peter Drucker, “The best way to predict your future is to create it.” This week, we’re exploring a simple but powerful technique that helps you do just that: drawing your vision.
instant asset write off
By Liz Gibbs June 9, 2025
If you've purchased or are planning to purchase business assets this financial year, keep in mind that the instant asset write-off threshold is $20,000 for the 2025 income year.
Problem solving
By Liz Gibbs June 5, 2025
Struggling with a tough business problem? You’re not alone—and the good news is, there’s a simple, team-friendly tool that can help you crack it. Meet CEDAC: the Cause and Effect Diagram with the Addition of Cards—a powerful yet practical upgrade to the traditional fishbone diagram.
Profitability
By Liz Gibbs May 29, 2025
Improving your business’s profitability doesn’t have to be overwhelming. The Profit Formula is a simple yet powerful tool designed to help you identify and implement strategies that can make a real difference. It focuses on three key areas: increasing sales, reducing overheads, and decreasing variable expenses.
vision mapping
By Liz Gibbs May 22, 2025
Today we explore vision mapping—a powerful framework to define and drive your business’s long-term success.
Cut Waste and improve profits by 30%.
By Liz Gibbs May 15, 2025
Did you know that waste can eat up as much as 30% of your operating costs? That’s a huge chunk of your budget! And yet, many businesses just accept it as part of doing business—focusing on increasing sales instead of fixing inefficiencies. But here’s the thing: why push more sales through a system that’s not running smoothly?
GIC not deductible from 1 July 2025
By Liz Gibbs May 14, 2025
From 1 July 2025, the General Interest Charge (GIC) on unpaid ATO debts will no longer be tax-deductible. That means holding onto tax debt could cost you more than you think, especially if you’re counting on the deduction to ease the burden.
Truck Drivers meal expenses
By Liz Gibbs May 13, 2025
In a recent decision, the Administrative Review Tribunal ('ART') upheld a truck driver's claim for meal expenses, notwithstanding that those expenses had not been fully substantiated.
work from home
By Liz Gibbs May 12, 2025
The ATO has updated its guidelines for claiming work-from-home expenses, making things a bit simpler for many people.
Clearance Certificates
By Liz Gibbs May 11, 2025
Just because you have a clearance certificate, it doesn’t mean you’re off the hook for other CGT (Capital Gains Tax) obligations.
More Posts